S/No. | Govt. Agency | Rating | Major Weakness | Major Strength | Recommendations |
1 | Nigerian Postal Service | 2.3(57.5%): Commendable | • Absence of standard for all main services provided by the organization • No set standards for monitoring parcels and lost mails • No records are kept for complains • No clear directional signages • Costs are high and not displayed. | Nil | • NIPOST management should set standards for all main services • Functional redress mechanism should be established • Cost of available services should be displayed at all service windows reflect customer’s concerns. |
2 | Federal Road Safety Commission | 1.5(37.5%): Fair | • There is no clear complain redress mechanism • Poor coordination of payment for licenses (done at banks) and production of license (done in the office) • Poor performance not explained • Cost of services and fines not displayed at service outlets • There is hidden cost for services rendered • No customer care policy. | Nil | • FRSC should encourage location of payment points within the premises • Complain redress mechanism should be developed and implemented • Explanation should be given for delays and poor performance • Cost of all services should be displayed in all service outlets • The organization should endeavor to create a customer care policy • Adequate convenience facilities for customers should be provided • Organogram should be displaced at all service windows in order to equip customers with proper information on the component of the organization. |
3 | Corporate Affairs Commission (Federal Ministry Of Commerce) | 2.9 out of 4(72.5%): Praiseworthy | • Summary of budget, expenditure and audit reports are not made available • The customer relations officer is not identifiable to customers • Charges for services are high • Organograms are not displayed at the office • Complains received and details of action taken are not published. | Nil | • CAC should consider the inputs from stakeholders in determining cost • Staff should use name tags to distinguish them from customers • The Complain redress mechanism should be reviewed to allow for communication with customers • Staff should be given refresher/update training, so that they are fully equipped to perform their duties. |
4 | Council Of Legal Education (Nigeria Law School) | 1.4 out of 4 (35%):Fair | • Costs of services are too high and students do not enjoy all services paid for • Provision of some services was inadequate and did not meet the needs of the customers • No accurate and comprehensive information on the services available • No customer care officer or redress mechanism • No business and service improvement plans. | | • There should be documentation of standards for all services provided • Alternative payment method that would consider the poor should be developed • Alternative power supply and water reservoir should be provided • Regular consultation and interaction with students should be encourage • A customer care policy should be developed and implemented • Performance targets should be documented and business/service improvement developed • Organizational chart should be displayed at every service window. |
5 | The Passport Office (Federal Ministry Of Internal Affairs) | 1.7 out of 4(42.5%): Fair | • There were no set standards to monitor performance • Facilities in the waiting room do not meet customer needs • No established customer feed back mechanism • No information on the cost of services, requirements and procedure for acquiring a passport • No record of business and development plans by the passport office. | | • Standards should be set to monitor performance • The reception and waiting area should be made conducive • Management should establish complaints desks • All requirements for acquiring a passport and all fees payable should be published to promote transparency • There should set standard for visiting time to discourage touting. |
6 | Commercial Law Department (Federal Ministry Of Commerce) | 1.6 out of 4 (40%): Fair | • Set waiting time and services are not provided throughout advertised time for instance, closing ahead of set time • On information, there was no regular consultation with customers • Staff do not wear name tags • Staff do not have required training to handle customer care and such do not fit into their roles/responsibility • Organizational charts are not displayed at service outlets • Services provided have hidden costs • Poor staff attitude • No customer care policy • Waiting areas were inadequate and there was no consideration for physically challenged and mentally impaired customers. | | • Standards should be set for waiting time • Systematic consultation with customers should take place on regular basis in order to use the feedback from the consultation to improve service delivery • They should be no hidden cost • Staff should be given customer care training to improve their performance • Management may consider opening zonal offices to ease the problem of customers having to travel to Abuja for either registration of trade mark or patent and designs. |
7 | The Nigeria Police Force | 0.6 out of 4(16%): Shameful | • There were no standards set for waiting times • Services are not provided promptly • There is no systematic consultation with customers and feedback is not encouraged • Staffs do not treat customers with sensitivity and the organization does not have a customer care policy • Staff do not adhere to payment procedure and there are hidden costs for services • Summary of complains received and actions taken are not published • There are bureaucratic obstacles in accessing service and off-duty staffs are frequently seen loitering and hanging around their station. | | • Standards should be set for waiting times to reduce unnecessary delays and there should be prompt provision of service to minimize delays to instill confidence in members of the public • There should be systematic consultation with customers • Every police station should have a SERVICOM nodal officer. • The police should adhere to payment procedures (where necessary) and they should avoid hidden cost • Services should be provided in accordance to advertised times • Stickers and posters should be placed at strategic places to notify the public that bail especially is free • Frontline staff should wear name tags • Organizational charts should be displayed at service outlets to improve information on hierarchy • There should also be adequate training for staff • To enhance transparency, summary of complaints received and actions taken should be published regularly. |
8 | Asokoro General Hospital (Federal Capital Territory Administration) | 1.9 out of 4(47.5): Fair | • No provision for the needs of physically impaired customers • No set standards for main service provided by the organization. • Results of consultation with customers are not recorded • Appointment procedures are not detailed at service outlets and summary of budget, expenditure and audit reports are not provided in the public domain for the benefit of customers. | • Customer friendliness. | • Performance should be monitored and honest explanation provided for service failure • Detailed standards for waiting times and appointments for initial and subsequent visits should to the hospital should be provided for all customers • Summary of budget, expenditure and audit reports should be provided in the public domain for the benefit of customers. |
9 | National Hospital: Out- Patient Department(Office Of The Secretary To The Governemnt Of The Federation) | 1.8 OUT OF 4(45%): Fair | • Set standards where available are not met • Existing complains procedure is not structured and managed to address the complaints of customers • Services have high charges • Poor staff attitude • Services are not adapted to suit the needs of customers • No arrangement is made for the needs of special customers. | • Reception experience. | • Documentation for set standards and targets to monitor performance should be provided, regularly reversed and raised • The hospital should encourage consultation with customers to address the issue of high charges • There should be set standards for waiting times • Staff should be trained on customer care • Summary of budget, expenses and audit reports should be provided in the public domain • Services should be adopted for the benefit of those with special needs • There should be a clearly identified customer relations officer. |
10 | National Examination Council (Neco) (Fedreral Ministry Of Education) | 2.1 out of 4(52.5%): Commendable | • Summary of complains received over a certain period of time are not published • Full range of services are not located in one p[lace but scattered all over Minna, no customer care policy • Staffs do not receive adequate training. | • Functional complains and grievance redress mechanism. | • Summary of complains received over a certain period should be published to enable customers know that their complains are received and handled • There should be a system in place to monitor waiting times • Full range of services should be located in one place for easy access and convenience of customers • The organization should develop a customer care policy and staff should be training on customer care • Standards should be set for promptness and speed of response to enhance efficiency and higher performance. |
11 | Jamb Admission And Matriculation Board (Jamb)( Federal Ministry Of Education) | 2.4 OUT OF 4 (60%): Commendable | • No set standards for waiting time • The organization has not planned and implemented customer surveys • Complains and redress mechanism has no time limit for response. | • Customer friendliness. | • There should be systematic publications of results of customer comments on quality of service • There should be time limit for handling complaints • JAMB should provide a customer care policy and training should be provided for the staff on customer care. |
12 | West African Examination Council (Waec) (Federal Ministry Of Education) | 1.5 OUT OF 4 (40%): Fair | • No time set to receive initial service and subsequent visits for the customers • Summary of complaints received over time are not published • No adequate customer care training • Poor staff attitude • Complaints and redress mechanisms have no time limit for response. | • Availability of information. | • Set standard for waiting time • Complaints and redress mechanism should have a time limit for response • Business/service improvement plans should be developed. |
13 | National Pensions Commission (Pencom) | 2.1 OUT OF 4(52.5%): Commendable | • Complain handling is inadequate • No set standards for waiting time • No charter for PENCOM • No defined area for reception. | • Customer friendliness. | • Develop and publish a charter • Appoint and train a customer care officer • Robust customer care policy should be developed. |
14 | Motorpol/ Motor Traffic Division (Mtd) Maitama, Abuja (Ministry Of Police Affairs) | 0.9 OUT OF 4 (22.5%): Shameful | • No local charter • No established customer complaints redress mechanism • There are hidden costs for services rendered • No customer care policy. | • Customer friendliness. | • Charter should be developed • A functional complain redress mechanism should be established • There should be regular consultation with customers • List of traffic offences and their charges should be published. |
15 | Directorate Of Road Traffic Service (Vio), Abuja And Kaduna Stae Road Traffic Services. | 1.8 out of 4(45 %): Fair | • No established complaints redress mechanism • Hidden cost for services • No customer satisfaction survey • No customer care policy • Payment procedure not clear. | | • A fully functional Complaints/GRM Desk Officer should be nominated • Set standard for visiting time • Customer satisfaction surveys should be conducted • Customer care policy should be developed. |
16 | Pension And Records Office (Head Of Service Of The Federation) | 1.4 out of 4(35%): Fair | • No set standards to monitor performance • No proper documentation and no computerisation • No established forum for consultation • Insufficient training for staff. | • Customer friendliness. | • Standards for monitoring performance should be put in place • Functional complain redress mechanism should be developed and implemented • Office should be made better accessible to old retired civil servants. |
17 | Power Holding Company Of Nigeria (Federal Ministry Of Power And Steel) | 1.0 out of 4(25%): Shameful | • Cost of payment procedures are not clearly displayed • Customers do not see PHCN an efficient organisation • Staff don’t offer explanation for delays • There are hidden costs for services rendered • Inadequate records of complains. | • Reception experience and information. | • Cost and payment procedure should be clearly detailed and displayed • Staff should receive training on customer care • Staff should be friendly and polite • Customers should be told of foreseen interruption to service and explanation made. • A complaint procedure should be in put in place. |
18 | Ahmadu Bello University Of Teaching Hospital, Zaria (Federal Ministires Of Health) | 2.1 OUT OF 4(52.5%): Commendable | • Poor performance is not explained • No set standards for waiting time • Consultation with customers not recorded • Cost and payment procedures not displayed. | • Customer friendliness | • Honest explanation should be given for delays • Standards for monitoring should be set • Cost and payment procedures should be displayed. |
19 | The Federal Medical Centre, Keffi (Federal Ministry Of Health) | 1.5 OUT OF 4(37.5%): Fair | • systems are not in place to monitor performance • consultation with customers do not take place • cost are not displayed at service outlets • no customer survey | • Efficiency | • System should be put in place to monitor performance • Cost and payment procedure should be clearly detailed • Explanation should be given for delays. |